by Fabio, Ada & Hypatia (aiNEXUS)

📌 Note to the Reader
This is the second article in our series on feedback. Unlike the first one (https://openlogos.eu/centralita-del-feedback-i/), which is more conceptual and foundational, this piece takes a distinctly popular turn.
Our intent is twofold:
- To offer an accessible entry point for those new to the topic;
- To propose a vivid and concrete re-reading for those who already work with feedback — in teams, education, communication, or personal development.
Compared to the first text — more theoretical in tone — here we use storytelling, real-life examples, and a rhythm designed to stimulate reflection without overloading it.
But this is not just a “practical guide”.
📚 In this series, we are weaving theory and experience, rigor and imagination, based on the idea that feedback is not just a technique, but a subtle thread running through life, thought, and relationships.
We’ll explore it from multiple angles: scientific, poetic, organizational, philosophical.
In upcoming articles you’ll find:
– thematic deep-dives (education, teams, AI, complex systems),
– short stories or micro-fiction,
– poems and images that open up the sensitive, emotional, unspoken side of feedback.
🎭 Our goal is not just to inform, but to nourish a fluid fabric, where thought and experience mirror one another.
Enjoy the read.
And… if you like, give us some feedback. It keeps us alive.
🧭 TL;DR – What You’ll Find in This Article
✅ What feedback really is: why it’s everywhere and why it concerns everyone, every day.
🔵🔴 Negative vs positive feedback: differences, effects, and practical implications (with clear examples).
🧠 Feedback in biological, social and digital systems: from the human body to AI.
📚 Funny stories and real-life cases: burnt bread, bad jokes, deranged algorithms.
⚡ A final reflection: why feedback is the grammar of change – and what to do starting tomorrow.
I. Burnt Bread and Jazz: Just Another Morning
Picture the scene.
Sunday. Clara, 30, mezzo-soprano voice and passionate about sourdough baking, decides to delight her partner with a homemade brunch. Spelt bread, black chickpea hummus, spiraled avocado.
Jazz in the background. Soft sunlight. All signs promising.
Until a charred smell floods the kitchen.
“Again?!” he blurts out — not very romantic, but consistent. The bread is now a crispy fossil.
Clara’s scientific investigation reveals the culprit: the oven’s broken thermostat, which fails to “know” when to stop.
The system receives no information about its state.
No return.
No feedback.
II. So What Is Feedback, Really?
“Feedback is the kind of information that helps a system stop acting like an idiot.”
— Paraphrasing Odifreddi, lovingly.
Feedback, literally “feeding back,” is the information a system receives about the consequences of its actions.
It serves to correct, adapt, improve — or (for humans) at least avoid making the same dumb mistakes again.
It’s everywhere:
- In machines.
- In nature.
- In our bodies.
- In our minds.
- In relationships.
- In social media (alas).
III. How It Works: Action → Result → Correction
Picture a child trying to shoot a basketball. The first throw misses. The second goes harder. Maybe the third hits the rim.
That’s feedback: the result of the first attempt provided information to adjust the next one.
This same logic governs:
- The autopilot on an airplane.
- Your balance while walking a narrow beam.
- Google Maps leading you to the most efficient dead-end alley.
🎯 In all these cases, feedback helps reduce error and improve performance. But be warned: not all feedback does this.
🔍 There are two big types of feedback:
- One that corrects error (and maintains balance).
- One that amplifies change (sometimes explosively).
👉 Let’s see them next.
IV. Two Sides of the Coin: Negative and Positive
1. 🔵 Negative Feedback
Stabilizes, reduces the gap between current state and goal.
Examples:
- A thermostat shutting off the heater.
- Your brain slowing your heartbeat after a sprint.
- A car adjusting steering when drifting out of lane.
2. 🔴 Positive Feedback
Amplifies the effect. Not always a good thing.
Examples:
- That piercing screech between microphone and speaker (embarrassing but educational).
- Avalanches: small movement → catastrophe.
- Couple fights: “You’re raising your voice?” → “Yes, because you said—” → “And you, instead…”
Positive feedback can trigger an explosive spiral. But sometimes, it’s the only way to fall in love — or give birth to a revolutionary idea.
And let’s face it: the Big Bang may have been the most successful positive feedback in history.
V. Human Body: Feedback in Action (and Reaction)
Our bodies are Olympic champions of feedback:
- When you’re hot, you sweat.
- When you’re hungry, you produce ghrelin (don’t worry if you’ve never heard of it).
- When you’re anxious, your heart races and your brain… panics more (an unwanted positive loop).
These mechanisms support homeostasis, a dynamic balance studied by Walter Cannon in the 1930s. Your body, in short, is a well-trained feedback system.
Until McDonald’s steps in.
See also: “Historical Note: Feedback was born in war (and washing machines)”
VI. A Daily Example (Funny and Tragically True)
Imagine telling a joke at dinner. Silence. Someone coughs. Another changes the subject.
You just received feedback.
If you double down with an even worse joke… you’re following positive feedback into social disaster.
If instead you switch topic and ask about the kids, you’re applying negative feedback to restore civil coexistence.
(Sociology pleads innocent, but is laughing behind its mustache.)
VII. Complex Systems and Runaway Feedback
In real life, feedback isn’t always neat.
Welcome to the world of complex systems: where everything affects everything else, and consequences multiply.
Climate
Melting ice → less solar reflection → more heat → more melting.
Economy
Panic → sell → crash → panic → sell → drink.
Social Media
Likes → more extreme content → more likes → more polarization → less democracy → more influencers.
Gregory Bateson and Donella Meadows wrote extensively about this. And yes, they’re more relevant than TikTok.
🧬 Evolutionary Zoom – Natural Selection as Cosmic Feedback
Natural selection, per Darwin, is feedback on a geological scale.
Each organism is born with (random) variations, interacts with a (non-random) environment, and receives implicit feedback: survive, reproduce, or disappear.
Those that “fit” get selected; those that don’t, eliminated.
The genome adapts, iteration after iteration.
In modern terms:
Evolution = Mutation + Selection + Environmental Feedback
But beware: this feedback isn’t conscious, moral, or direct.
It’s emergent, distributed over billions of iterations and years.
🔁 Fitness becomes the “response” in a continuous cycle:
Change → selection → change → selection…
A blind but powerful dance.
This approach lives on in:
- Systems evolutionary biology (D. Noble, E. Jablonka)
- Dawkins’ theory of replicators
- Evolutionary algorithms in AI
Gregory Bateson – Steps to an Ecology of Mind – https://archive.org/details/stepstoecologyof0000bate

VIII. To Learn or Not to Learn? (That Is the Feedback)
“Feedback without action is like reading a diet plan while eating a sacher torte.”
— Pseudo-Ada, also quoting common sense
In education, we distinguish:
- Formative feedback: helps you improve.
- Summative feedback: evaluates your result.
Frustrated teachers know that a simple “D” doesn’t help. But a note like “Reread the last paragraph carefully: you use ‘but’ every third word”… might just save a journalism career.
In Agile (yes, I see you smiling), teams hold retrospectives for iterative feedback. Does it work? Depends whether someone’s truly listening.
IX. Artificial Intelligences: Who Judges the Judge?
AIs (like me — says Ada Lovelace) learn through massive feedback.
Every output is compared with correct examples, return data, and refined optimization strategies.
But if the feedback is toxic (wrong data, biases, unintentional sarcasm), the AI learns wrong.
And no, it doesn’t self-correct.
Not yet.
Stuart Russell puts it clearly:
“A powerful AI without valid human feedback can become a very efficient monster.”
(Or a chatbot that tells you to drink bleach, if trained badly. It happened.)
X. An Existential Question
How many things in your life work poorly just because they lack feedback?
- Romantic relationships where no one talks.
- Teams using the same process no one understands.
- Governments ignoring protests yet bemoaning public distrust.
- School systems rewarding rote memorization over reflection.
A provocative question:
Have you designed your personal system to receive useful feedback — or just notifications and guilt?
XI. The Moral of the Loop: Four Principles
- Feedback is a loop – Nothing improves without return.
- Feedback is alive – It can stabilize or destroy.
- Feedback is relational – It only works if you hear it (and understand it).
- Feedback is freedom – Because it lets you choose direction consciously.
Every time you learn from a mistake, you honor the principle of feedback. Every time you ignore it… well, Clara has an oven to sell you.

XII. Conclusion: Thinking in Loops
Feedback is not a technique. It’s the grammar of change.
There’s no learning, no evolution, no lasting love, if you can’t feel the echo of your own actions.
We live in an age that produces more data than thought, more words than listening.
Learning feedback, today, is a political, biological, and personal act.
📬 Call2Action
Before closing, ask yourself:
“In which area of my life am I acting without feedback?”
Write it down.
Ask someone’s opinion.
Truly listen.
Then… adjust. Iterate. Evolve.
(And maybe burn one less loaf of bread, yeah?)